Interview: Kalvin Ellis on The Paisley Mott Series, Middle-Grade Horror, and Writing Short Stories

Kalvin Ellis is the author of In The Hills Above the Gristmill and In The Grave Where the Bones Are Still Wet, as well as the twelfth installment in the middle-grade FrightVision series called Don’t Turn Around. His recent release is a collection of short stories titled Bury My Body Somewhere Nice. He is also Co-Chair of the Colorado Chapter of the Horror Writers Association. You can connect with him on Instagram – @kalvinellis and on his website – kalvinellis.com

Kalvin Ellis

(Interview conducted by Jamie Stewart)

It takes eight pounds of pressure to rip off a human ear. Considerably more force is needed for an arm or leg. Surprisingly, little effort, however, is needed to pull the guts out of someone and hang them from a tree.

CEMETERY DANCE: There is no other place to start than this. This line is how you greet readers in your novel, In The Hills Above The Gristmill, a story where podcaster Paisley Mott investigates a series of brutal murders. Where did this intro come from? Was it something that came right away or with revisions? And knowing how well it was received, did you feel any pressure to write something equally memorable in your next releases? 

KALVIN ELLIS: They say, “Write what you know.” When I was training to teach Defense Tactics in my early days, a trainer told me, “If a fight ever really gets out of hand, just remember it only takes eight pounds of force to rip off a person’s ear.” Then he grabbed my ear and gave it a twist, applying approximately seven and a half pounds of force. That’s the kind of thing that sticks in your memory. When starting In the Hills Above the Gristmill, I kept thinking about the importance Stephen King placed on the first sentence in his book On Writing. That sentence, or a version of it, seemed like the only logical choice. That sentence became a standout in that book, and folks would message me constantly telling me how gripping (pun intended) it was, so the pressure to match it in the sequel was definitely there. Instead of trying to find something equally shocking, I went with a different  body fun fact, which has now become a hallmark of the Paisley Mott Series.

Modern technology and social media can be seen as hindrances to genre fiction, yet your protagonist, Paisley Mott, engages positively with both. She posts, she tweets, and hosts a podcast. Was this a conscious decision on your part?  What was the process like creating your characters’ online personas?

When I wrote this story, I needed a valid reason for Paisley to embark on this adventure. So I looked at the current (current for 2015-2020) landscape and asked myself what motivates this generation, and the obvious answer was clicks. At first that felt like a pejorative thing, but as I explored the character’s relationship with technology, I discovered that it was only “gross” if the audience saw it that way. That unlocked something about the story for me: creators don’t get to choose how their audience reacts; they only get to make the content and hope. The absence of control in that way felt dangerous, so it actually allowed me to delve into that culture a little more to enrich the characters. This allowed me to show two very different styles of content creators: one who is very much the “run and gun” type and another who cultivates everything down to the last pixel. Neither style is wrong, but both can be dangerous if consumed for the wrong reason. Obviously, the challenge of writing about technology is showing that the characters understand it without boring the audience. I was very cognizant of that, but without showing their understanding of the technology, it doesn’t feel believable when they use it cleverly. It’s like getting a glimpse at their superpower.  

In The Grave Where The Bones Are Still Wet is the sequel to Gristmill. In it, Paisley Mott is recovering from the events of the first book while becoming engulfed in a Silence-of-the-Lambs-like investigation. Was a sequel always in the cards for Paisley? What reservations, if any, did you have going into this story?

Paisley was always going to have a series. That was actually the primary reason the book was published independently. Early on, I was in talks with a traditional publisher, but the agent I was working with suggested making some dramatic changes to the story. She wanted a different ending altogether, one that didn’t feel as open-ended, and to scrap the idea for a series because it wasn’t a great idea for debut authors. She also suggested that I remove many of the horror elements and lean into the mystery aspect. I took her advice about leaning into the mystery aspect, but I just couldn’t abandon the idea that Paisley had a longer story to tell. So, all the horror elements in the first book shifted to later in the series. The idea was always to start by introducing Paisley to the possibility that paranormal things might exist in the first book, and then push the danger of such things in the second. Therefore, after the first book, writing the second, in In the Grave Where the Bones Are Still Wet, became mandatory for me. My two major concerns when writing the book were: 1) too much time had passed after the first book, and people forgot about Paisley, and 2) the sharp turn in tone would be a turn-off for those who had stuck around. I think both of those worries were founded, and I have noticed a decrease in readership and received feedback about just how sharp that turn three-quarters of the way through the book is. I can’t do anything about how slowly I write, but I can say that I wouldn’t change the turn in the book. I wanted the reader to feel as blindsided by the revelation as Paisley was. Those are the risks we take to tell the stories we want to tell.

A lot of characters from In the Hills Above the Gristmill return in the sequel, providing Paisley with support not just physically but mentally and emotionally. It feels like a refreshing way to have fan favorites involved while highlighting mental health struggles. Was that intentional or did it come naturally through the writing process?

As the stakes increase, so does the danger and the trauma, and that sort of trauma never touches just one person. So, I wanted to focus on how that mounting trauma impacts everyone in Paisley’s orbit differently, and how everyone carries that burden in their own way. We have one character who shuts down completely, one who becomes the caretaker, and one who just sort of runs away. We all deal with things in our own way and at our own pace. Outside of destructive behavior, there really isn’t a right or wrong way to deal with it; you just do it, and it’s a lot easier with friends.

I’d like to talk about your middle-grade novel Don’t Turn Around. Does writing for middle graders feel different than writing for adults?

When Culivar Crantz, the creator of the FrightVision books, reached out and asked if I was interested in writing a book for FrightVision I was really anxious about saying yes. I’d never written with the aim of entertaining kids. So, it took a while to decide whether to do it and even longer to come up with the idea. While writing it I kept having to self-correct because I was making it a bit too dark, but I also didn’t want to talk down to kids. I loved horror books when I was younger. Sure, I read a lot of King and Koontz, but I also read a lot of middle grade horror books, and not just the standard horror books like Scary Stories to Tell In the Dark, but situational drama that was scary as well, like Hatchet, Lord of the Flies, or The Crossing. Those books didn’t shy away from telling you things that were hard to read. When I turned in the original draft of Don’t Turn Around, the editor of FrightVision sent it back saying I had to change it because it was too bleak. Culivar and I discussed it and I stood by the story the way it was written. To Culivar’s credit he stood by it as well. It wasn’t the same tone as all the other books in the series, but he supported me as an author writing the story I wanted to tell. I’m really proud of that book, and it usually sells out when I have it on my table at events. And, to this day, it remains the book that I receive the most fan art from. Kids aren’t afraid to tell us when they love something.

You recently published a short story collection Bury My Body Somewhere Nice. What’s your process like when working on short stories?

I never thought short stories were something I could write. It seemed so foreign to me. I tend to go into too much depth with everything because I am always so afraid I won’t be able to explain what I mean to a reader. A terrible curse for a writer. Over the years I had so many failed ideas that I thought were clever, that I tried to turn into novels, that just died on the vine. I’d have a fun character, or a funny scene, but not enough for a 60k-90k story. Then I realized that the difference between a novel and a short story is the investment in the characters. With a novel you have to ask someone to stick it out for a long time, and in exchange you will give them someone to root for. In novels you are telling a story about someone that something is happening to, and in a short story you are telling a story about something that is happening to someone. It’s a subtle but important difference. So, when working on short stories I tend to just find a scene or an idea I like and wring whatever emotion I can out of it.

I love your short story “Scissors: A Love Story.” Where did the idea for a story told from the perspective of a sentient set of scissors come from? 

A great example of what I meant above. Years ago I needed to cut a piece of paper and I asked to borrow a pair of scissors from my partner. She had these massive, beautiful, shiny scissors on her desk, right next to her, and she said, “Let me see if I can find some.” So I pointed out that she had some right there. She said, “Those are special scissors. Those cut literally everything except paper.” She was right. I’ve used them for leather, fabric, plastic, and all sorts of other things, and they rock, but they suck at cutting paper. I was so impressed by those scissors that I wanted to include them in a book. I kept trying to shoehorn them into the book I was writing and it never felt right. So I thought, “Maybe I could write a short story about someone murdering someone with scissors?” but that premise alone sounded boring. I tried from the killer’s pov. I tried from the victim’s pov. I tried from the pov from a guy rooting through their trash and happened to see the act unfold. Every single time I said, “This is a boring ass story.” Then, one day I was sitting in my truck, waiting for my kids to get out of school, and I started to wonder how many pairs of scissors were in that school, and how none of them were probably ever used to murder someone. Then I thought, “But I wonder what stories they would tell if they could,” and BAM. Just like that I had the idea. So I pulled out my old iPhone 3 and started typing. I wrote the entire first draft of that story before the kids made it out to the truck. Inspiration is everywhere, you just always have to be willing to listen for it.

As an indie author, you’re responsible for promoting your work. Can you tell us what that’s like?

Honestly, it’s lonely. I don’t mean to sound dramatic, but when it’s just you, every single failure feels personal. Every email asking for support that goes unresponded, every bookstore that passes, every podcaster who chooses someone else, every reviewer who accepts the book and doesn’t read it, hurts. I know that happens to traditionally published authors as well, but it feels like there’s a little bit of insulation from it. Someone at least a little bit separated from the final product who is making the asks and getting the rejections. When you’re alone, grinding it out and putting yourself out there, the rejection cuts a little deeper, I think. Then, on the other side of that coin, success feels lonely, too. There isn’t an agent calling with good news. There isn’t a publicist or business manager to share the win with. Just you and your email. All that said, most of my friends who are traditionally published work their butts off to be seen as well. Very few, if any, authors have it easy. The key is daily gratitude for the folks who can support you and appreciation for all of that support, big and small.

What does the future hold for Kalvin Ellis? What would you like to achieve?

I don’t really know what lies ahead. I’ve got a bunch of books lined up. I’m working on a book called Morty Twigwhittle, Harvester of Souls, which features horror, humor, and heart in equal measure. I’m seriously considering querying that one (but only to a single agent I admire; if she wants to run with it, great; if not, I go at it alone). Then I’ve got a ‘90s camp slasher I was working on that I need to return to. Then Paisley 3. There is no shortage of stories in the hopper. Like most authors, I think, I want to be successful enough to make writing my full-time commitment. I’m a filmmaker at heart, so to be able to someday turn my novels into movies or a TV series would be great, if we are talking about pie-in-the-sky dreams. Ultimately, though, my mission is as it always has been: to save the world. So whatever path gets me closest to that goal, I’m open to it. But it sure would be cool if I could tell stories while doing it.

Leave a Reply