It Looks Like You In The Dark by Mathilda Zeller
Tor Nightfire (October 2026)
Reviewed by Abby Wolf
Horror has always been effective at giving shape to fears that can be otherwise difficult to articulate. A monster can be just a monster, but it can also become an embodiment of grief, violence, environmental destruction, or generational trauma. The supernatural allows us to see the consequences of human behavior made flesh. With It Looks Like You In The Dark, Mathilda Zeller uses that tradition to explore the collision between Indigenous communities, colonial exploitation, and the terrifying consequences of treating both people and land as resources to be consumed.
At the heart of the novel is Tapeesa, a young Inupiat woman living in the Alaskan village of Chukchi. Tapeesa knows the stories passed down through her family, including the legend of the kushtuka, a predatory creature capable of assuming the appearance of someone you love in order to lure you away from reality. It may seem like a simple piece of folklore, but Zeller shows us the horrors in its implications. The kushtuka isn’t only terrifying because of what it does. It is terrifying because it weaponizes familiarity. It turns recognition into vulnerability and makes a person we instinctively trust indistinguishable from what is hunting us. This idea becomes increasingly important as Tapeesa searches for her missing sister, Esther.
Her disappearance unfolds against another threat moving into the Kobuk River Valley. A mining operation arrives, backed by outsiders who see the region in terms of what can be extracted from it. Zeller does not need to utilize any supernatural elements to make that horrifying. The history of Indigenous land being desecrated for someone else’s economic benefit is already riddled with violence. By placing the kushtuka alongside that history, Zeller creates an unsettling parallel between supernatural predation and colonial exploration. Both take something, and both violate boundaries. And both depend on people failing to recognize the danger until it is already far too late.
This is where It Looks Like You In The Dark becomes much more than a creature tale. The horror is inseparable from the novel’s examination of what happens when an isolated community is forced to negotiate with outsiders who, holding bags of money, promise prosperity while threatening to permanently alter the environment. The mining operation presents a complicated dilemma. Economic opportunities can be desperately needed, but accepting that opportunity comes with consequences that may be irreversible. Zeller doesn’t reduce that conflict to a standard good vs. evil scenario. Instead, she dials up the tension to an uncomfortable level. That discomfort only strengthens the supernatural horrors.
The monster itself becomes part of a larger conversation about consequence. Folklore isn’t included just to give It Looks Like You In The Dark its scary creature. It provides a framework through which Tapeesa and her community understand that danger. These stories carry knowledge. They communicate ideas that might otherwise be dismissed by those who have never experienced such a threat. In that sense, folklore becomes its own form of survival.
That makes the novel’s title all the more effective. It Looks Like You In The Dark suggests that our inability to distinguish the familiar from the dangerous can be much more frightening than a monster waiting in the dark. Darkness removes clarity, and without clarity, recognition becomes unreliable. What our heart wishes to see becomes palpable, clouding anything we have ever been told. Zeller builds much of the novel’s tension around that uncertainty, repeatedly asking what we can trust when even our own eyes are deceived.
The environmental aspects of the novel work closely with the narrative. The landscape is remote, isolating our characters. Zeller conveys that the land is its own presence and has its own history, one that existed for far longer than any people who now attempt to profit from it. The vastness of the Alaskan setting becomes both beautiful and threatening, while the darkness and solitude amplify the feeling that Tapeesa is stepping into a realm where the rules she understands no longer protect her.
Yet, amid the atmosphere of isolation, Tapeesa’s story remains deeply personal. Esther’s disappearance gives the novel its axis, transforming broad questions about land exploitation into something more immediate. Tapeesa isn’t pursuing justice. She is trying to bring someone she loves home. Her determination gives the larger themes more humanity.
Zeller also resists making the horror about victimhood. Tapeesa and her community possess knowledge, history, resilience, and agency. Their relationship to the land and their storytelling isn’t presented as quaint or mystical for an outsider’s benefit. It is how our Indigenous characters and people see their world. That distinction matters.
It Looks Like You In The Dark examines what happens when people stop listening to stories, history, the land, and to one another. Zeller takes the familiar machinery of folk horror and casts light onto forces that are considerably less fantastical than the supernatural. Greed, manipulation, environmental destruction, and cultural erasure have all produced human monsters throughout history.
The brilliance of Zeller’s approach is that she didn’t choose between real-life horrors and a supernatural one. They coexist, feed one another, and make each other all the more terrifying. As a debut, It Looks Like You In The Dark announces Mathilda Zeller as an author with a powerful storytelling hand. Indigenous folklore remembers for us, and we inherit warnings about what happens when we forget.
